Poker Face TV Series Peacock ★★★★

Are you looking for a TV series that is comical, creative, and fun to watch? “Poker Face,” the crime-solving comedy-drama streaming on Peacock, is fantastic as the lead, Natasha Lyonne, who plays Charlie Cale, has stylized her mannerisms, crazy looks, and facial expressions to captivate all. Starting with her long, curly red hair, sunglasses, trucker hat, loud clothing, and those baseball socks, Charlie is a force to be reckoned with. This distinctive style reflects her unique personality and tenacity, making her a character you won’t easily forget.

POKER FACE — Pictured: Natasha Lyonne as Charlie Cale — (Photo by: PEACOCK)

The writer and director Rian Johnson also gave her excellent supernatural power; she could actually tell when a person was lying. Certainly, a skill that aids in her investigation, as typically a murder is to be solved when she’s questioning people. This remarkable skill adds an intriguing layer to the narrative, as it aids her in navigating the complex world of crime and deception.

Rian Johnson Critics Choice Awards Hollywood, January, 2024  Photo Credit: Sarah Knight Adamson

A murder mystery typically unfolds as Charlie engages with various suspects, skillfully uncovering their secrets while utilizing her gift to reveal the truth. Under the direction and writing of Rian Johnson, “Poker Face” offers moments of humor and invites viewers to solve thrilling whodunits. The show’s combination of comedy and suspense ensures that audiences are thoroughly entertained. Whether you’re drawn in by the laughs, the tension, or the unique character interactions, “Poker Face” guarantees an engaging experience that is hard to resist.

Natasha Lyonne Critics Choice Awards Hollywood, January, 2024                                                                                          Photo Credit: Sarah Knight Adamson

Former fans of the show “Columbo” (1971-1990), starring Peter Falk as a detective, may appreciate the unique storytelling approach of this whodunit series. Unlike most detective shows, where viewers are kept in the dark about the criminal’s identity until the police or detectives uncover the clues, “Columbo” and “Poker Face” reveal the crime and the perpetrator at the beginning of most episodes. The real mystery and enjoyment for viewers come from trying to spot the clues that lead Charlie Cale to identify the culprit and observing the clever strategies she employs to elicit a confession.

The first season debuted on January 26, 2023, and the second season premiered on May 8, 2025. Each episode for season 2 will drop once a week, as there are 14 in all. Due to the show’s popularity, many Hollywood actors want to be on the show, just like Seth Rogen’s “The Studio” with Martin Scorsese in his first episode. Season 2 kicks off with “Poker Face” starring Adrian Brody in a lead role, along with Giancarlo Esposito, Katie Holmes, and Cynthia Erivo. A similar pattern occurs in each episode: we witness a murder, of which the stars may play either the victim or the culprit. Then we view Charlie in different locations, somehow getting involved in investigating the crime.

As you can imagine, so many different scenarios can appear in a crime scene, as well as in Charlie’s carefree life. She’s basically a ‘human lie detector,’ where the fun begins with her at the center unknowingly to the culprits taking charge, as due to her unconventional looks and demeaner they underestimate her, which is all part of the fun as typically she has the case solved and in on a mission to solve the crime. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed the show from the beginning as I appreciate the creative writing involved, watching the outstanding actor Natasha Lyonne, and getting a kick out of seeing the guest stars.

Rian Johnson Critics Choice Awards Hollywood, January, 2024
On a side note, I met Rian Johnson and Natasha Lyonne as they sat next to my table at the Critics Choice Awards in 2024. I told Rian that I was at the Toronto Film Festival in Toronto, September 2019, when “Knives Out” premiered to a standing, roaring ovation with all the cast coming across the stage to take bows. I also talked with him about chatting on the Red Carpet. It was one of my most iconic experiences as a film journalist. Rian also wrote and directed that film. I said to him that his creativity in screenplay writing is incredible, and I for one appreciate his work and simply wanted to thank him, and from that moment I was looking forward to what he was going to write next, of which “Poker Face” the TV show was next.
Sarah Knight Adamson© May 17, 2025